Star Trek: Picard, S1.2: “Maps and Legends” is Star Trek’s answer to CSI…


The second episode of Star Trek: Picard, “Maps and Legends”, written by series’ creators Michael Chabon, Kirsten Beyer, Alex Kurtzman, Akiva Goldsman and directed (once again) by Hannale Culpepper has been released on CBS-All Access and Amazon Prime (overseas). This particular episode plays like a procedural drama; more “CSI: Starfleet” than Star Trek at times.

Maps and Legends.

Opening on the planet Mars of 2385 (14 years before Picard’s present of 2399), we finally see the Federation’s “9/11” that led to both the abandonment of Romulan refugee rescue operations (following the destruction of their home system) and a complete ban on the construction and development of artificial life forms, aka “Synths” (like Picard’s late friend Data).

The grim prediction Picard and Guinan both made in TNG’s “Measure of a Man” had come to pass by 2385; armies of Data’s progeny becoming the Federation’s ‘disposable creatures’…

On “First Contact Day” of April 5th of that year, we see human workers on Mars working alongside Synth workers, though in a decidedly inequitable relationship (exactly the kind of exploitative relationship Picard forecast for Data’s ‘race’ if Starfleet developed more like him). The cybernetic beings are derisively referred to as ‘plastic faces’ in a chillingly racist taunt that feels very out of character with TNG’s original vision of the 24th century. One android, F-8 (Alex Diehl), goes rogue, lowering planetary defense systems, allowing a planet-wide attack with other rogue Synths which killed thousands. This devastating attack was also chronicled in the Short Trek mini-episode, “Children of Mars” released a couple of weeks ago.

The Synth attack on Mars is like a Federation equivalent of the United States’ 9/11 attacks on the World Trade Center.

On Picard’s chateau in present day La Barre, France, Picard is still examining the circumstances around the death of the mysterious organic-Synth woman Daj (Isa Briones), who died seeking Picard’s protection. All visual records of her existence, including her death near Starfleet Command Headquarters, has been erased from the visual logs. Picard consults with his two loyal Romulan friends, Laris (Orla Brady) and her husband Zhaban (Jamie McShane), both of whom used to work for the Tal Shiar (the Romulan Secret Service).

Picard and his loyal Romulan aides, Laris and Zhaban. The warmth of their bond goes beyond the screen, suggesting a backstory that begs telling someday.

Beaming over to Daj’s now vacant apartment in Boston, Picard and Laris go over the scene of the crime (this is where the episode gets pretty thick in CSI-style technobabble). Former Romulan operative Laris goes over the visual logs and deleted records with her unique skillsets and manages to recover fragment records of both Daj and her late boyfriend, who was killed by Romulan assassins. Now they have evidence of her existence, however fragmentary. Daj certainly existed.

Picard and Laris go full CSI in Daj’s former Boston apartment.

Back at the chateau, Laris tells Picard of an even more secretive, more powerful agency that oversaw the Tal Shiar, called the “Zhad-Vash”; they are ‘ghosts’… thought to be more legend than reality, but Laris is convinced that the Daj coverup reeks of their handiwork… much to Zhaban’s chagrin. Picard believes her, and plans to go to Starfleet Command and procure a starship in order to find out the truth. Laris and Zhaban warn him he won’t be safe against the Tal Shiar or the Zhad-Vash, but Picard plans to call in a few favors…

Narek and Soji.
Don’t get your milk where you make your bread, kids…

Aboard the “Romulan Reclamation Site”, where Romulan and human scientists are working in secret to reverse-engineer technology from a damaged, dormant Borg cube, the late Daj’s twin sister Soji (Isa Briones) is having a secretive relationship with the young Romulan Narek (Harry Treadaway). Both are not inclined to make their clandestine affair public, for both their sakes. Narek doesn’t seem to be entirely trustworthy, either…unlike the more gregarious Soji, who is most likely being used by Narek for some nefarious purpose relating to her artificial origins. As Laris told Picard earlier, the Romulans are deeply distrustful of artificial intelligence, and have never allowed AI or androids within their society…

Picard and his former ship’s Doctor…and no, it’s not Beverly Crusher.

Picard receives a visit from his old medical officer (pre-TNG) and friend, Dr. Maurice Benayoun (David Paymer), in the hope that he will certify him fit for duty. Maurice tells Jean-Luc that in most of his scans, he seems perfectly healthy for a man of his age, but there is some doubt regarding the parietal lobe of his brain (possibly early traces of his irumodic syndrome, alluded to in TNG’s “All Good Things…”).

San Francisco, circa 2399…love the idea of the Golden Gate as a massive solar power station.

The next morning, Picard beams in to San Francisco, home of Starfleet Command. Walking into the familiar building fills Picard with nostalgia, as he sees large holographic images of various starships named Enterprise (including Pike’s version of the 1701, and Picard’s 1701-D), hovering in the space above the foyer. Picard tells a young man at the desk he has an appointment with the Starfleet CIC, Admiral Kirsten Clancy (Ann Magnuson). There is an awkward moment as the young man doesn’t seem to recognize the Starfleet legend, prompting a mildly irked Jean-Luc to spell out his last name. Realizing his tactlessness, the young man sheepishly gives Picard a visitor’s badge.

Picard and a receptionist who’s not exactly up on his Starfleet legends…

Picard’s meeting with Admiral Clancy goes terribly. Assuming his legendary status in Starfleet would get him a ship with no questions asked, Picard forgets the effect his recent disastrous interview had on his reputation within Starfleet (“such f–king hubris” the admiral exclaims), especially when he accused the organization of moral cowardice in discontinuing help of the Romulan refugees following the Syth attack on Mars. The admiral tells Picard to do what he does best, “Go home!” Note: Admiral Clancy’s name of Kirsten is an obvious nod to aforementioned writer/producer Kirsten Beyer, who was a Star Trek novelist before she landed her producing/writing gigs on both “Discovery” and “Picard”…

Picard the unstoppable force meets an unmovable object, in the form of Admiral Kirsten Clancy…

His request denied with extreme prejudice, an angered Picard leaves Starfleet, though still determined to learn the truth about the death of Daj, and the location of her twin sister. The story thus far reminded me very much of “Star Trek III: The Search For Spock” (1984), which also featured a Starfleet hero, Kirk, whose request for a starship to learn the truth of his loyal friend Spock’s death (dismissed by the admiralty as “Vulcan mysticism”) was similarly denied. At least Admiral Morrow didn’t drop the f-bomb when talking to Kirk.

Picard, looking a bit more like his grumpier, TNG-Season 1 self…

I had a couple of nits with the Admiral Clancy scene which I’ll go into later on, but for now, suffice it to say I thought the scene as written and played was a bit of overkill. Clancy could’ve just denied Picard’s request without the handwringing melodrama, or the f-bomb. Given that she was talking to a Federation hero who’d saved the universe on multiple occasions, she could’ve denied his request with a bit less venom (again; see Admiral Morrow turning down Kirk in Star Trek III). Moving on…

Soji’s mastered one trick her old dad never did–a beaming smile.

Back aboard the reclaimed Borg cube, Soji tries to calm a newbie on the project who is worried about working on the dead/dormant Borg, as well as their own live Romulan coworkers, who love to play up the drama of their working environment, such as the radiation badges they wear. The affable Soji assures her she’ll be fine.

Soji and Narek… It got weird, didn’t it?

Soji runs into Narek, but keeps it cool and professional. Coworkers with benefits. When he presses her about seeing her again, she brushes it off, saying he has to make an appointment with her supervisor, blah, blah, blah. As she walks away, Narek sinisterly adds, “Actually, I don’t have to.”

Who ever thought the Borg would be at the mercy of humans and Romulans someday?

Consulting with the Daystrom Institute’s Dr. Agnes Jurati (Alison Pill), whom he met last week, Picard and the cyberneticist are also trying to piece together the mystery surrounding Daj’s existence and death…as well as the location of Daj’s surviving “twin” sister, Soji, who is currently harvesting Borg implants from dead and dormant Borg drones aboard the Borg cube. Feeling overwhelming empathy for the Borg drones on the lab tables in front of her, Soji removes a cranial implant, speaking to the dead Borg in an alien tongue, “You are free, my friend.”

“Picard to Musiker…please don’t hang up!”

Meanwhile, back at the ranch–er, chateau, Picard tells his two Romulan friends that he’s determined to call in favors and get back into space to find Daj’s sister, and solve the mystery of his dear departed android friend Data’s progeny. Laris thinks he’s gone mad. Her husband Zhaban offers to come with him. Laris tells him they’ll both do no such thing! Against their wishes, Picard pulls out his old Starfleet comm-badge, walks outside, and looks up into the starry night sky. He then taps it in activation, calling out to his ex-first officer (again, post-TNG), Raffi Musiker (Michelle Hurd), pleading with her to listen…

Commodore Oh (Tamlyn Tomita, “Babylon 5″).
Oh is the first commodore we’ve ever seen in the 24th century (the rank seemed to had fallen into disuse late in the 23rd). Look very carefully and you may also notice the tiny Starfleet delta insignias on the golden fabric of her uniform, much like the uniforms seen in 2009’s “Star Trek.”

Commodore Oh (Tamlyn Tomita), an apparent Vulcan-human hybrid, consults with a young human Starfleet officer named “Lt. Narissa Rizzo” (Peyton List). Oh is concerned about Picard learning the truth about Daj’s murder, and through dialogue with Rizzo, it appears that the two of them are actually Romulan operatives (dun, dun, DUUUUNNN!) who’ve infiltrated Starfleet Command, and are planning some sort of action against Picard…

Recognize those rocks?
It’s Vasquez Rocks, in California. The very place where Kirk first fought the Gorn in TOS’ “Arena” (in fact, they’re now nicknamed “Kirk’s Rocks”). They were also seen in TOS’ “The Alternative Factor,” “Friday’s Child” and TNG’s “Who Watches the Watchers?” They were also seen in “Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home” (1986) and “Star Trek” (2009), twice being used to represent the planet Vulcan.

Picard catches a shuttlecraft Taxi to a remote patch of desert somewhere (not 100% sure if it’s supposed to be Earth, or another Earth-like planet). There, he finds the small mobile home of his ex-first officer (again, post-TNG) Raffi Musiker. Musiker, like Picard in his French chateau, seems to be in her own self-imposed exile from the rest of the world. Apparently, Picard and his last “Number One” didn’t part company on the best terms, as she pulls one hell of a mean-looking weapon on her ex-captain. She tells him to go back and catch another taxi home. With Picard’s arms up in surrender, she notices that he brought a bottle of vintage Chateau Picard wine, which is an apparent weakness of hers, and she grudgingly accepts the peace offering…for now.

Picard gets a less-than-warm welcome from his last Number One…

The location of Musiker’s home is the real-life Vasquez Rocks Natural Area Park (nicknamed “Kirk’s Rocks”), northeast of Los Angeles…the shooting location of many Star Treks, including TOS’ “Arena” and TNG’s “Who Watches the Watchers?” as well as the TOS film, “The Voyage Home” and 2009’s “Star Trek”).

Narek and “Lt. Rizzo” are up to no good, I suspect…

Back aboard the Borg cube, Narek is visited by a hologram of the duplicitous “Lt. Rizzo”, and he makes a comment about how ridiculous she looks with “rounded ears.” Apparently the Romulan operatives in Starfleet Command are working in conjunction with their counterparts in the Borg cube. To what end, isn’t exactly clear yet, but it has something to do with Soji…

The End.

Sussing It Out.

“Maps and Legends” is less of a story and more a series of connective threads between stories. It’s the glue by which more intriguing parts of the overall arc will be conveyed later. This is an unavoidable consequence of serialized storytelling. The connecting threads are certainly necessary, but as an episode it feels like it’s alluding to something better just over the horizon. “Maps…” is certainly not a bad installment, and the feature film-quality direction by Hannale Culpepper (who also directed last week’s outstanding first episode, “Remembrance”) makes it look gorgeous. However, this episode suffers the issues of being a middling chapter of a novel where events happen, but not those grand events that come to define the story.

Laris uses her not-quite-legal-in-the-Federation field equipment to do a CSI on Daj’s old apartment…

The beginning portion of the story where Picard and Laris go to Daj’s apartment in Boston feels a bit too “CSI Starfleet” at times, with a heavy reliance on technobabble. Not to mention the total ease with which Picard and Laris just beam over to a crime scene, which, from the looks of it, hasn’t been fully cleaned up yet, either. Did Laris use her former Tal Shiar skills to pull that off, or do citizens of the Federation just go wherever they want to go, without restrictions, even to the scene of a very fresh multiple homicide? I don’t know if the Boston investigation scene/flashback was left vague on purpose, or if it might be revisited later on (doubt it), but there were bits of technobabble they could easily deleted in favor of fleshing out the basic mechanics of this scene. What they found at the apartment was almost less interesting to me than how they got into the damned place so easily.

Welcome to Starfleet Command…Disneyland is juuuust over to your right, across the street.

Once again, we see Picard return to Starfleet Command… once again shot at the Anaheim Convention Center, right across from Disneyland, I kid you not. I go to this location often for WonderCon, as well as other events, such as the Star Wars Celebration (in 2015, and later this year). I gotta say, the architecture of the location is perfect as the retro-futuristic Starfleet HQ, and the production team is careful to dress it up very subtly…keeping the overall look and feel of the site intact. Last week’s “Remembrance” also saw the exterior of the Convention Center’s Arena auditorium as well (as the Quantum Archive), where most of the biggest panels and screenings of the conventions are usually held.

Picard’s old ride, the USS Enterprise 1701-D, from Star Trek: The Next Generation.

The beautiful holographic images of changing Federation starships high above the foyer was quite an eye-catcher. Right before we see Picard’s old ship, the Galaxy-class USS Enterprise, NCC-1701-D, we also catch a glimpse of the original Constitution-class Enterprise, NCC-1701.

This is the version of Pike & Kirk’s old ship that appeared in holographic form in the foyer of Starfleet Command. Not quite as she appeared in TOS Star Trek, though superficially similar…

The Constitution class appears to look like Pike’s newer version of the ship, as seen in Star Trek: Discovery for much of its second season. This implies that this is how the Constitution class always looked in this timeline, with the window viewscreen, and slightly swept-back warp nacelle pylon supports (among other subtle changes). If this is so, it falls in line with my personal belief that every Star Trek episode or film, post-“Star Trek: First Contact” (1996), is part of a subtly altered version of the TOS timeline.

More on this pet theory of mine here:

Clancy vs. Picard.
I had issues with this scene, and not just for the somewhat out-of-place f-bomb…

I had a couple of issues with Picard’s scene with Admiral Clancy. To be honest, that f-bomb she dropped felt a bit out of place…as if the writers threw it in to sound ‘edgy.’ Now, I certainly have nothing against a solid curse word or two (thousand), but it’s a matter of placement. “Your damned hubris” might’ve worked just as well, and might’ve felt more “Star Trek.” Granted, Picard’s disastrous interview in “Remembrance” last week didn’t do him any favors at Starfleet Command, but I find it hard to believe that single interview cost him so much good will…especially since his heroic old starship still lights up the foyer of Starfleet Command. It’s not as if Picard left after betraying Federation to an enemy, or something so shameful. Picard disagreed with leadership and resigned in protest. That was it.

Resigning in protest hardly merits Picard’s newfound status as a Starfleet pariah, especially after saving the Federation on so many occasions…

^ That sign made me chuckle.
I like that it also has a Romulan language version to the right of it as well.

A nice bit of gallows-humor in the Borg cube “Romulan Reclamation Site” B-story, with a workplace sign stating “This Facility Has Gone 5,843 Days Without An Assimilation.” This is a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment, so I thought it was worth mentioning.

The scenes of Romulans stripping Borg of their implants aboard a reclaimed Borg cube have a very non-Star Trek, almost blue-collar vibe to them. I can imagine Deep Space Nine’s Chief O’Brien getting assigned to this detail, if it were a Starfleet operation…which it clearly isn’t.

In fact, the work environment aboard the Borg reclamation site is portrayed like shift workers punching in at a nuclear power plant, or some other risky, blue-collar job. They don’t quite feel like researchers…just a group working in secret to strip the Borg of their technology and reverse-engineer it. Clearly whatever they’re doing isn’t Starfleet sanctioned (or is it?). Perhaps it has to do with the dreaded Starfleet Black Ops unit Section 31? What little they’ve shown so far has certainly made me curious to see its (intended) end result.

Orla Brady as Romulan Laris convincingly goes toe-to-toe with Picard.
I’ve heard some fan feedback regarding her Irish accent, which is an odd criticism, since the Star Trek universe has a galaxy full of English-speaking aliens who all sound as if they all live in Los Angeles. Irish accents are a no-no, but American accented aliens are just… okay, somehow (?).

While this episode didn’t quite have the impact of last week’s “Remembrance”, “Maps and Legends” succeeds in telling its portion of the 10 episode arc, if not as a fully satisfying whole. I had a few minor issues with the writing, as the episode has a written-by-committee feel to it at times. On the plus side, the actors are strong in their roles; Isa Briones continues to impress, as does the headstrong Orla Brady (I love her Irish accented Romulan, Laris…she’s charming as hell, in my opinion). Producer Hannale Culpepper’s smooth direction is so wonderfully cinematic that even a lesser installment in this series looks better than many current science fiction movies playing theatrically. I’m still looking forward to the next installment of “Star Trek: Picard,” of course, but I’m going to have to remind myself that each episode is but one chapter in a 10-chapter novel, and temper my expectations accordingly. I’m guessing it’ll all flow much better once I can stream the 10-part story at once (ala Netflix), rather than week-to-week.


Images: CBS-All Access/

17 Comments Add yours

  1. While I agree there are a few rough points (the scene with the admiral was indeed laying it on a bit thick), I think I actually enjoyed this more than the pilot. It does a great job of answering questions while opening up new ones, and it really drew me in.

    Also, Laris and Zhaban are absolutely delightful, and it’s almost tragic that they’ll probably be sidelined once Picard returns to space.

    In general I’m loving seeing the Romulans finally be put into the spotlight. Could this finally be the moment where Romulan culture gets the loving attention the Klingons have enjoyed? As a longtime Romulan fan, I can only hope so.

    As much as it’s a small thing, I also love how much they’re continuing to lean on established alien races, even for extras. Trill, Andorian, and it was very quick but I think I even spotted a Denobulan on the Borg Cube.

    This is definitely the most I’ve enjoyed Star Trek since Enterprise went off the air.

    One nit-pick: The old medical officer mentions serving with Picard on the Stargazer, so he’d be pre-TNG, not post-TNG.

    1. Slip of the keyboard. Must’ve missed that. Will edit immediately.


  2. Paul Bowler says:

    I enjoyed this episode of Star Trek Picard. It continues to set up the shows premise very well. Loved seeing the holograms of the Enterprises at Starfleet hq. I didn’t like the way the F Bomb was dropped in this episode though. It just docent suit Star Trek IMOP. Star Trek was always a family show to me, and I don’t like how the F Bomb keeps getting thrown in so indiscriminately. Other than that, great episode.

    1. Yeah, that f-bomb just felt so…anachronistic. Like the language used for the Mars miners, too; they sounded more like something out of a James Cameron movie.

      Other than that, yeah, it was solid.

      1. Paul Bowler says:

        Agreed. I’m no prude or anything, but I just hate it when they drop the F Bomb in Star Trek, it just doesn’t feel right. They do this a lot with Discovery, which is a darker show at times I know. But with Picard it just seemed so out of place and unnecessary.

      2. scenariodave says:

        Picard said that Starfleet isn’t Starfleet anymore. Admirals swearing, ranks that hadn’t been used in a century coming back, they’re all symptoms of the decay in Starfleet. The people running Starfleet now wouldn’t have gotten through the door 30 years ago.

      3. That’s a possibility, I agree, but for me, it wasn’t so much a moral lapse as it was a lapse in how Star Trek dialogue works.

        The miners on Mars, for example; they sounded like supporting characters in a James Cameron movie.

        Star Trek used to have a very specific cadence to its dialogue, almost a poor man’s Shakespeare, and that f-bomb just didn’t fit. Even a good ‘goddamned hubris’ might have done, but f–k just felt…weird. Not that I mind the word on any kind of moral grounds (I’ve used it plenty), but in that context it just didn’t work (for me, anyway).

  3. scenariodave says:

    To me the crime scene isn’t an issue. There was no crime scene. When they got there the Romulans got there first and cleaned everything up. Who’d report the crime? Daj didn’t report the crime. She ran to Picard. Noisy neighbors are a thing of the past. Play your music on 11 and he neighbors won’t hear.
    The Romulans who cleaned up were pros. They probably left messages that the happy couple had gotten married and were having a honeymoon on Risa. See you in a month.

    1. Being a former apartment dweller, I imagine someone living below her would’ve reported the screams and the noise, but you’ve made a good point that it’s possible the crime wasn’t yet reported. But given the screams I find that iffy…

      1. scenariodave says:

        What screams? This is the perfect world. Apartments have had thick walls or dampening fields or something for generations. I doubt that a world that has no hunger or disease would still have a problem with noisy neighbors. In a world of transporters you could work in China and live in Boston. Your middle of the night is their middle of the day. The problem of people living above you making too much noise is a thing of the past.

      2. That’s debatable at best. Even in TNG they could hear noises from next door cabins aboard the ship.

        And reiterating the point about the admiral’s language and Starfleet’s corruption, this clearly isn’t the perfect world we thought it was.

  4. scenariodave says:

    Three points about the dialog.

    Pilots and air traffic controllers all around the world use a special form of English all around the world to avoid confusion. Maybe what we’ve been hearing is StarFleet English.

    The Federation is big. There’s no reason to assume that everyone speaks Star Fleet English.

    In TOS, there was a magical plot device called the Universal Translator which had the ability to perfectly translate all languages as the plot needed. Maybe Picard has been speaking French all along but we hear him speaking Star Fleet English because its being translated for us. But if we hear people talking other places we are hearing them how they speak.

  5. scenariodave says:

    How would the police work in ST? I think it would be something like this.
    There is a phone call to 911 (999 in other countries).
    The person said that there was a hair raising scream from the room next door.
    The person or machine that answers the phone codes it, possible emergency.
    All the computers (Siri’s) in nearby rooms are contacted and asked if there was a scream.
    Recording of scream is sent back to police headquarters.
    Scream analyzed and results indicate extreme distress and probable crime in progress.
    Police swat squad beamed to location of probable crime in progress.

    Time from first call to police arriving, 10 to 20 seconds.

    The Romulan Ninja’s know the potential of a quick police action. They would have taken steps to be sure that no one outside of the apartment heard anything. They wouldn’t have been sloppy enough to be detected by outsiders.

    1. Yeah, but they were all killed too, so they were at least a little sloppy…😉

      1. scenariodave says:

        True but the were the cannon fodder not the leaders. A second group came in a cleaned up later.

Leave a Reply to A Middle Aged GeekCancel reply