Star Trek: Discovery 1.11, “The Wolf Inside”…

I just saw the latest ST Discovery episode “The Wolf Inside” and the good news is that its got all ten fingers and all ten toes (except for Saru, of course…).   But some of the ‘surprises’ of the hour were a bit belabored in anticipation; so much so that they lost some of their shock value by the time the characters finally caught up with them.

That issue aside,  I found “The Wolf Inside” to be pretty darn entertaining.   And staying (for now) in this hostile dimension keeps our characters nervously swimming with the sharks every week.  I’m not sure I’d want a ST series to be permanently based in the mirror universe, but for the remainder of this season?  I’m okay with it.

img_8437

******SPOILER TORPEDOES WILL NOW BOMBARD THIS BLOG!!******

The Story.

dsc-111-preview-201-640x320

The opening sees the Discovery (still disguised as the ISS Discovery in this universe) getting electrical repairs (fluctuating between lightness and darkness; an apt metaphor for where they are) as Paul Stamets, still semi-lucid and catatonic in sickbay, gently cradles his dead lover Dr. Culber in his arms, and goes on about a dark forest.  

We then see Burnham aboard her mirror “ISS Shenzhou” quarters, contemplating how to survive in this hostile universe, and how to hide her basic Federation decency in a place where weakness of any sort could get one killed.   

dsc-111-preview-003-640x320

After Burnham attends a death-by-transporter execution of several disloyal crewmen, she’s back in her quarters getting a bit of much-needed affection from her increasingly shaky lover, Lt. Ash Tyler (the murderer of Dr. Culber).  Burnham also finds that her ‘hand-servant’ in this universe is mirror-Saru, who is just a nameless alien here (“Slaves have no names,” he explains).   She ‘assigns’ him the name Saru, in honor of ‘a friend.’  Burnham then discreetly accepts a couple of carefully coded holographic ‘hang in there, kid’ calls from both Tilly and prime-Saru, who both decide to keep the news about Dr. Culber’s murder from her for now (given that she has enough to worry about, right?).  Saru also reiterates to Burnham the importance of acquiring data regarding the lost Federation starship Defiant’s entry into this universe.  It’s hoped that data might help them get back to their own universe.  

img_8436

Back on the Discovery, prime-Saru and Tilly incorrectly assume that Culber’s murder was the work of his post-spore jump lover, Lt. Stamets, who’s still semi-catatonic, with milky-white eyes.   For his own sake, Stamets is bound to his sickbay bed while Tilly formulates a plan to treat Stamets’ catatonia with his own ship-grown spores.  Her hope is that the spores will reconnect the parts of Stamets’ brain that are still out of reach. 

img_8438

Back aboard the ISS Shenzhou, Burnham receives new Imperial orders to proceed to the planet Harlack, and eradicate a rebel base led by a rogue Klingon. Despite orders to destroy the planet, Burnham decides to beam down with Tyler and ‘get intel’ which could ‘help’ the Terran Empire eradicate ALL of the rebels everywhere. 

img_8439

Burnham confers with a post-tortured Captain Lorca (still in the agony chamber) about what to do; he tells her to follow orders and wipe them out.   Lorca (who is obviously native to this universe) doesn’t seem terribly conflicted about destroying the rebels in favor of their mission.  But Burnham argues that the rebels consist of various races (Andorians, Tellarites and even Klingons) working together in the closest thing to a Federation she knows of in the mirror universe, and she will not destroy them outright.   

dsc-111-preview-101-640x320

She and Tyler beam down to Harlack to negotiate with the rebels, who (of course) attack and capture her, according to her plan.  She tells Tyler to throw down their weapons and surrender to the rebel Klingon leader “Firewolf.”  Her plan is to convince them to evacuate and destroy the planet (per Imperial orders) ONLY when the rebels are safely evacuated. 

img_8442

The rebels assemble to ascertain the truth about Tyler and Burnham.  It turns out that the Klingon rebel leader “Firewolf” is the mirror universe’s Voq (the albino Klingon who was surgically altered to become Ash Tyler in the prime universe).   Ash is literally facing his old self.  

dsc-111-preview-105-640x320

Voq asks the Vulcan rebel “prophet”, mirror-Sarek (Burnham’s adoptive father in the prime universe) to uncover the truth about Burnham’s intentions.  After melding, Sarek is confused with Burnham’s true Federation identity, but he reveals to Voq that she can be trusted.  

dsc-111-preview-103-640x3201

Voq agrees… and Tyler, of course, feeling his old Klingon impulses attacks Voq (while speaking Klingon no less…).   Tyler is attacking his former self.  Voq and the rebels manage to restrain him, and Sarek still maintains that despite her guard’s attack, Burnham is trustworthy.  The rebels agree to evacuate.  Burnham gets her rebel intel data, which will be inactionable by the time the Terrans can use it, and returns to the ship.  

Back aboard mirror-Shenzou in Burnham’s quarters, Ash finally comes clean to her, and the s#!t truly hits the fan.  His Klingon-self fully comes out, revelations fly.  

dsc-ep111-reminder-header

He then attacks Burnham and grabs her weapon.  Tyler knows details about Burnham’s combat with Voq (in “Battle of the Binary Stars”) that only Voq could know.   As Tyler/Voq advances his attack, mirror slave-Saru stops the attack and Tyler is whisked away for immediate punishment.  He is sentenced to die by transporter for betrayal of his ‘captain.’   Burnham, still pretending to be her more hardened mirror-self, beams Tyler/Voq off of the ship and into space herself….

star2btrek2bdiscovery2btimothy2bpeel2buss2bshenzhou2bui2btransporter2broom
^ Transporters; the mirror-universe’s answer to gas chambers…

….but Tyler/Voq is snatched from death by vacuum via Discovery’s transporter.   Saru tells  Tyler-Voq that despite his own wish to die, Discovery is still a Federation starship, and that he will remain alive, (per Starfleet protocols) as a prisoner.  

dsc-111-preview-203-640x320

Despite her best efforts to bring him out of his catatonia with his own spores, Tilly observes helplessly as Stamets’ condition worsens.  Within his own catatonic state, Stamets’ minds briefly ‘meets’ his mirror-self.   Stamets’ body then flatlines, and Saru allows a medical team within the spore chamber in an effort to revive and stabilize him.   Tilly is devastated that her idea to treat him has not only failed, but may have worsened his deteriorating condition (or even killed him?).

Aboard mirror-Shenzhou, Burnham is notified that another Imperial ship is in orbit and has began an orbital bombardment of Harlack.   Burnham is mortified as she knows that the rebel base hasn’t been fully evacuated; even though she is not at fault, it appears to the rebels that she’s broken her word.   

dsc-111-preview-004-640x320

An even bigger surprise awaits as Burnham learns that the bombardment of Harlack was the work of the Terran Emperor herself; mirror-Philippa Georgieou… the mirror counterpart to Burnham’s beloved dead captain.  The Emperor’s hologram appears on mirror-Shenzhou’s bridge and demands that Burnham return her salute.

discovery-wolf-inside2

The End.

So much to discuss.

This was an episode that was satisfying overall, but there were also a few nagging issues that were not easy to ignore.  First the positive

 

What I really liked about “The Wolf Inside”:

*   Ash Tyler (Shazad Latif) has finally came clean.

rx7k8kphvgsi7ucj4xtq

Something that was speculated about since Tyler’s initial appearance in “Choose Your Pain” is now out in the open.  No more ambiguity.  No more lies.   Ash Tyler is Voq.  And while this outing wasn’t exactly a big reveal to the audience, the emotions it triggered within Michael Burnham gave Sonequa Martin-Green some terrific moments, all played to perfection.  For that alone it was worth it.  His death sentence by transporter (while somewhat mitigated by Discovery) felt justified, and at least Burnham got to give him a nice punch in the gut to go with the harshness of vacuum.    I’m very much anti-death penalty, but after the brutal murder of the kind, affable Dr. Hugh Culber?  I was ready to deep-fry this f–ker.

*  Emperor Philippa Georgiou (and the return of Michelle Yeoh)

discovery-wolf-inside2

I’ve missed Michelle Yeoh’s Captain Georgiou since her way-too-early exit in the 2nd episode “Battle at the Binary Stars,” and while I realize that this emperor incarnation of the character is not the same woman (obviously), it’s just so great to have Yeoh back that I don’t even mind that she’s playing a complete monster.   Hell, if anything, maybe she’ll get a chance to show off some of her formidable martial arts skills in the mirror universe (?).   At any rate, it’s great to have the actress back in any form.  And seeing her hologram, in royal gold robes no less, standing in front of a destroyed planet… man, that was one HELL of an re-entrance. 

*  Mirror-Sarek, ‘the prophet’ (James Frain)

star2btrek2bdiscovery2b1x112bthe2bwolf2binside2btrailer2bscreencap2b252852529

Vulcans are pure awesome sauce (or plomeek soup).  And actor James Frain’s interpretation of Sarek is slowly growing on me, despite my worship of the late Mark Lenard’s original (and an appreciation of Ben Cross’ version in the 2009’s Star Trek).  Sarek’s presence as a rebel leader shows that a schism between Sarek and his son Spock still exists in the mirror-universe as well, since we see mirror-Spock serving serving as First Officer aboard the Terran Empire flagship ISS Enterprise in 1967’s “Mirror, Mirror.”  One wonders if mirror-Sarek survived the orbital bombardment or was he one of the rebels that escaped in time?  Here’s hoping the latter…

*   Sylvia Tilly (Mary Wiseman)

Still one of my favorite characters because she is the most human and relatable.  She’s still rocking her “Captain Killy” mirror-hairdo (very flattering, by the way…) as she places her ‘hang in there’ call to Burnham, and as she tries to find a way to bring back Stamets’ conscious mind using the spores.  I got a chuckle out of her concern with the upward trajectory of her career as she gently asks Saru if he will consider granting her acceptance into the command program.   Spoken like the future captain we know she will be someday.

dsc-111-preview-204-640x320

And Tilly’s seeming failure to affect any positive change in Stamets’ condition near the end is quite heartbreaking.  Her tears feel both earned and authentic (once again, a credit to the talented Wiseman).   A part of me wishes that the show were told from her perspective, as she’s a far more human and relatable audience avatar than the occasionally aloof and inscrutable Michael Burnham.

 

And here’s what I wasn’t so crazy about…

 

*   The big reveals weren’t so surprising

voq-tyler-2

As stated earlier.   From Tyler/Voq’s (Tyvoq?) finally coming clean about his Klingon self, to the speculation over who the emperor would be (one guess; Georgiou) the biggest fireworks of the hour were both predicated on ‘surprises’ that we, the audience, kinda figured out a while ago. It’s always more fun when the characters and audience share a mutual surprise.   Granted, these ‘revelations’ were coming sooner or later, but here’s hoping the next surprises of the show aren’t so telegraphed in advance.   Speaking of which, can they just go ahead and reveal that Lorca is from the mirror-universe already?

*  The fight between Burnham and Tyler/Voq in her quarters

This was a BIG nit for me.

dsc-ep111-reminder-header

Michael had a phaser trained on Tyler/Voq for much of the time, and he was unarmed.  Did she really have to go through that tired cliche of walking backward with a weapon trained on him while he kept advancing long enough to knock it out of her hands?   This is the same Michael Burnham who showed no such hesitation giving her beloved captain of seven years a Vulcan neck pinch and rendering her unconscious in “The Vulcan Hello.”   But, for some reason, she couldn’t bring herself to just stun Tyler/Voq?   Sorry, but I cry ‘bulls#!t’ on that one.  It was far less dramatic having slave-Saru rescue her than it would’ve been for her to have to stun her lover herself.   That cliche set Burnham back a bit, in my opinion…

*  Did Tyler/Voq really need to survive this episode?

www-cbr_-comdiscovery-tyler-neck-f47ac468ed1c4be5cb0a35da054a8b2fa499227f

Like I’ve said, I’m not comfortable with the death penalty in principle, but these characters are stuck in this hostile mirror-universe for the foreseeable future, and Tyler/Voq is a traitor to both the mirror-universe (for betraying his ‘captain’) and to the prime universe (for being an awakened Klingon sleeper agent).   Oh, not to mention the fact that he murdered Dr. Culber in cold blood.  That action has generated a lot of internet anger, especially to some LGBTQ fans who perceived Culber’s death as the old cliche of ‘killing off the gay character.’   Even if Culber is resurrected somehow, it won’t redeem Tyler/Voq for me.   No offense to Shazad Latif, who is a terrific actor (and I love it when he speaks Klingon in his human guise; it’s chilling), but I see no path to redemption for this character nor am I in a particular hurry for him to find one.

*   If the flatlining Lt. Paul Stamets (Anthony Rapp) dies, there’ll be serious fan rage… 

dsc-111-preview-header

And it’ll only cement the fan theory/belief that all characters of diversity on the show are slowly-but-surely being killed off.  First, we lost Asian captain Philippa Georgiou in the 2nd episode, then we lost one half of the first openly gay couple in Star Trek’s history (!), and now an actor (Shazad Latif) of Pakistani descent is being revealed as a traitor and a Klingon sleeper agent (though I won’t shed too many tears if Tyler/Voq dies, to be honest, and not for any personal prejudices).   The only characters of any diversity left on the show are the openly gay Lt. Stamets and a black woman, Michael Burnham.  If Stamets dies, the show will be raining some serious holy hell upon itself, and for good reason.

This is Star Trek, not The Walking f–king Dead.   You didn’t see the classic series knocking off Sulu, Uhura and Chekov…

 

Summary
So while “The Wolf Inside” was an entertaining episode, it does have more than its fair share of issues.  Nice mirror-character reveals and moments of adventure are offset by a few unfortunate choices.  But once again, my inner-optimist reminds me that most Star Trek series are often a bit rough in their early years, and DSC isn’t entirely immune to that affliction it would seem.  At any rate, “The Wolf Inside” is still very enjoyable, despite its flaws.

There is still more than enough positive going on with this show overall for me to maintain my present course…

episodes-5-9_feature-image-1024x509

 

SaveSave

Advertisements

7 Comments Add yours

  1. Kibbin says:

    You complain about saving Ash when that was one of the stand out bits for me. Seeing the dark and dingy crew of the Discovery try to represent the light of the Federation even in this dark universe were something that I enjoyed. Especially seen as how they not only kept him alive to face justice for what he had done but also used him to get data to the Discovery without the Empire noticing was quite clever.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I see what you mean, but I just think Tyler/Voq is too dangerous/deadly to keep around, especially considering their precarious situation. Even Spock was willing to sacrifice a crewman or two in TOS’ “The Galileo Seven” to save the remaining shuttlecraft passengers. Voq is little better than any other Klingon combatant, save that he resembles a human and that he duped poor Burnham. But…your point is well-taken.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. shd says:

    Same here. I thought that was a pretty powerful statement, one that, along with Michael’s determination to save the rebels, also cemented ST:Disco’s relationship with the whole “optimism” and “positivity” aspect that so many ST fans are loudly complaining that Disco lacks. It doesn’t lack those aspects – it just approaches them in a different way, one that is less wishfulfilment and more relevant to the current (well, perpetual) state of the world.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Exactly! Thanks for the insightful comment! 😊🖖🏼

      Like

  3. Corylea says:

    Yes, yes, SO MUCH YES to your nit #2! I was shouting at the screen when Burnham was holding the phaser on Tyler. I mean, geeze, we know those things have a “stun” setting, so it’s not like she had to KILL her lover! I just can’t buy that any Starfleet officer — much less one WHO WAS RAISED VULCAN — couldn’t stun the man who’d just revealed himself to be a Klingon agent.

    The only way I can make it make any sense to myself is to think that Burnham has been deliberately trying to get more in touch with her human side. It’s often the case that when a pendulum swings, it doesn’t stop at neutral; it swings to the other side first before swinging back. Our psyches act much the way that pendulums do, and I think Burnham may be very emotional at the moment, precisely because she has so little practice in doing anything with her emotions but bottling them up. That mitigates it slightly, but still doesn’t erase it. I still can’t see Burnham refusing to stun Tyler.

    I disagree about killing Tyler, though. It was through beaming Tyler aboard the Discovery that the show reaffirmed its commitment to Starfleet principles. We may be IN the Mirror universe, but WE are not Mirror. I thought that was perfect, actually; the show needed that reaffirmation of Starfleet principles, especially since they’re about to reveal that their captain is a Mirror guy. If he tries to make the whole crew Mirror-like, he’ll get some pushback.

    I think it would be really cool if Saru had to mutiny against Lorca; that would set Saru and Burnham up for a really deep, understanding relationship in Season 2.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Having seen the latest episode, my position on Tyler is…evolving. Have to see how it plays out. And thanks again for reading my blog. I’m humbled. 😊🖖🏼

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s